• 1 Post
  • 73 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 9th, 2023

help-circle




  • I wasn’t a customer of theirs (I’m always skeptical of super-popular-anything), but I think I’ll look elsewhere for secure email.

    Not because of this article, which I think makes some decent points, but because I would worry in the back of my mind that the Officers of the company would happily bow to their demigods and start secretly tracking people as a show of fealty.




  • It might be that they’re equating the name with the app and company, not the open source model, based on one of the first lines:

    AI chat apps like ChatGPT collect user data, filter responses, and make content moderation decisions that are not always transparent.

    Emphasis mine. The rest of the article reads the same way.

    Most people aren’t privacy-conscious enough to care who gets what data and who’s building the binaries and web apps, so sounding the alarm is appropriate for people who barely know the difference between AI and AGI.

    I get that people are mad at Proton right now (anyone have a link? I’m behind on the recent stuff), but we should ensure we get mad at things that are real, not invent imaginary ones based on contrived contexts.






  • You might not have read the other comments, but I do QA for a living. Devs fucking up commits is why I continue to have a job. Also, companies/maintainers aren’t required to capitulate to every bug report. It’s possible that whoever made the original comments didn’t understand why it was such a big deal and/or didn’t know of an alternative way to structure their software; public pressure made them look a little harder.

    Like I said in my first comment: you do you. Bring out the pitchforks. The fact that there’s reasonable candidate explanations other than malicious intent says to me that the internet is overreacting—again.

    Though, when has the internet ever done that, amirite? /s



  • Their inability to do the right PR things is just a signal that they can’t be bothered with the facade…

    …or they’re just bad at PR. It’s not a skill everyone has.

    Re: ethics, they are no longer on F-Droid because they tried to get this in under the radar…

    …or they made an honest mistake and don’t care to put it back on F-droid for reasons to which we are not privy. I bring up these counter-examples not as a way to point out where I’m right and you’re wrong, but to point out that there are other candidate explanations, and it’s not justified to infer that malfeasance is the only likely possibility.

    I also understand why you would cynically think that Bitwarden might succumb to Capitalism—I too live in a late-stage-capitalism country—but that’s not a forgone conclusion, and I say again that we don’t need to be imagining villains when there’s plenty of objectively real ones at which to point a finger already.