If you’re a spellcaster, sure, just for the stacking bonus to spell save DC and spell attack rolls. But then it’s better to compare it against a magic staff, not a shortsword…
For actually stabbing people, I think Knife of the Undermountain King is better.
I dunno, who told you Rhapsody is better and what was their explanation when you asked them how?
They argued that getting the kills for Rhapsody was easy and the effect lasted until long rest.
My argument was KOTUMK was more consistent.
Looks like Rhapsody has an ability I didn’t know about which lets you consume your +3 from Scarlet Remittance to either guarantee a crit, heal yourself, or give a target disadvantage on saving throws.
https://bg3.wiki/wiki/Scarlet_Feast
I still think which one is better depends on how many spells you’re going to be casting.
If it really lasts until a long rest thats pretty good. From 2 stacks onward the damage output should be better. +2(3) atk roll and +2(3) dmg vs +5% crit chance and ~+0.67 dmg from Organ rearranger
Better, for specific situations.
The attack and spell save DC bump at 3 is really damn solid for casters in specific. Pair it with some acuity, and hello guaranteed control spells.
As a weapon used by a melee fighter? Not at all.
